Smart shopping for busy families

Menu

Checking Deals

How to tell if a deal is real

A crossed-out "was" price is a claim, not proof of a bargain. A few quick checks on price history, unit cost, shipping and returns, plus some caution with giveaways, will tell you whether a deal is worth taking.

· 5 min read

Four blank white paper hang tags with strings on a pastel pink background
Four blank white paper hang tags with strings on a pastel pink background. Photo: Keila Hötzel / Unsplash

The trouble with "was" prices

Red tags, crossed-out numbers and countdown timers all send the same message: buy now, this is cheaper than usual. Sometimes it is. Sometimes the "original" price is a number the item rarely or never sold at, placed there to make an ordinary price look like a markdown.

This works because of how people judge value. When you see a high number next to a lower one, the gap feels like money saved, and you stop asking whether the lower number is actually a good price. The fix is simple but takes discipline. Ignore the crossed-out price. Ask instead what this item has cost recently, and what the same thing costs elsewhere.

Check the price history

Online prices move often, sometimes several times a week, as sellers react to demand and competitors. A price promoted during a big sales event can turn out to be no lower than an ordinary week earlier in the season.

Price history tools, including browser extensions and websites that track prices over time, can show how an item's price has moved. If the "sale" price turns up again and again, it is the normal price in practice, and there is no reason to rush. If the price is genuinely at the low end of its range, that is a real deal.

Without a tool, you can still keep your own notes. When you start thinking about a bigger purchase, write down the price and the date each time you see it. After a few weeks you will know what a good price looks like, and you will not be swayed by a dramatic tag.

Do the per-unit math

Signs about savings can distract from simple arithmetic. Packages shrink, multipacks change, and "buy more, save more" offers are not always what they seem.

On the grocery shelf, look at the unit price on the tag: per ounce, per pound or per count. A sale on a smaller package can still cost more per ounce than the regular price on a larger one. Online, you may need to divide the price by the quantity yourself. A bulk pack is a deal only if the unit cost is lower and your family will use it before it spoils or goes unused.

Count shipping and returns

A low item price can disappear at checkout. Some sellers keep the listed price low and make it up on shipping or handling. Before you compare deals, compare the total that will actually leave your account, including shipping, fees and tax.

Returns matter just as much. Some sellers charge a restocking fee, make you pay return shipping, or treat sale items as final. If there is any chance the item will not fit or will not work as expected, read the return policy first. A bargain you cannot return can turn into money spent on nothing.

Fake giveaways and sweepstakes scams

Giveaways can be a fun bonus, but they are also a common way for scammers to reach families looking to save. Fake pages and messages copy the look of real brands and announce prizes to collect personal details or money.

The Federal Trade Commission's advice is clear. A real sweepstakes does not ask you to pay to enter or to collect a prize. If someone says you won but must first pay a fee, taxes, shipping or a "processing" charge, it is a scam. The same goes for requests for your bank account number or card details to "verify" a win, and for any demand to pay by gift card, wire transfer or similar methods.

Be suspicious of messages announcing a prize for a contest you do not remember entering, especially through social media direct messages or texts. Do not click links in those messages. If you want to check, go to the company's official website on your own and look for the promotion there.

Read the official rules

Legitimate promotions publish official rules. Reading them takes a few minutes and tells you whether the contest is real and what you are agreeing to.

Look for the sponsor's name and contact information, who is eligible to enter, the entry period, how many entries are allowed, how and when winners are chosen, and how winners will be contacted. The rules should also say what the prize is. Valuable prizes can come with tax responsibilities for the winner, and the rules often mention that.

Pay attention to what happens to your information. Many giveaways exist mainly to build marketing lists, and the rules may let the sponsor share your contact details with partners. Look for boxes to opt out of marketing. If the rules ask for broad rights to your photos or personal data, or if there are no rules at all, it is fine to pass.

A quick test before you buy

Before you click "buy" on a deal, run through four questions. What has this item really cost lately? What is the price per unit? What is the total after shipping and fees? Can I return it if it does not work out? If the answers still look good, it is a real deal. If you have to stretch to make them look good, it probably is not.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a sale price sometimes match what the item usually costs?

Some sellers show a high "original" price that the item rarely sold at, which makes an ordinary price look like a markdown. Judge the price you will actually pay against what the item has cost recently, not against the crossed-out number.

Do I ever have to pay to claim a sweepstakes prize?

No. The Federal Trade Commission advises that a real sweepstakes does not ask you to pay to enter or to collect a prize. A request for fees, taxes up front or your bank details is a sign of a scam.

What should I look for in official contest rules?

Who runs the promotion, who is eligible, how winners are chosen and notified, and what the sponsor may do with your contact information. If there are no rules or no clear sponsor, skip it.

More in Checking Deals